r/manavalue is where we talk new releases, prices and speculation.

MTG Secret Lair Value Breakdown

USD

Trick or Treat

5 cardsSecret Scare Superdrop

Trick or Treat is a 5-card Secret Lair drop that released on October 13, 2025 as part of the Secret Scare Superdrop, alongside 9 other drops.

The most valuable card in Trick or Treat is currently Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver, at $10.20 for its cheapest printing. The Secret Lair printings themselves cost $71.15, about 1.9× the $37.37 the same cards cost in their cheapest printings.

Non-Foil Total$37.37
Foil Total$36.34

Cards in this drop

More from Secret Scare Superdrop

Frequently asked questions

How much is Trick or Treat worth?+

Priced as singles at the cheapest printing of each card, the 5 cards in Trick or Treat come to $37.37 non-foil and $36.34 foil. Compare that against what the sealed drop sells for to judge whether it is worth buying intact.

What is the most valuable card in Trick or Treat?+

Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver, at $10.20 for its cheapest printing. It is followed by Voja, Jaws of the Conclave at $9.77 and Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose at $9.74.

When did Trick or Treat release?+

Trick or Treat released on October 13, 2025, as part of the Secret Scare Superdrop. It contains 5 cards.

Where do the prices for Trick or Treat come from?+

From TCGplayer, refreshed regularly — the currency you pick decides which marketplace is shown, Cardmarket in EUR or TCGplayer in USD. Mana Value does not sell cards; every price links back to the marketplace listing it came from.